Showing posts with label All-Star Batman and Robin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label All-Star Batman and Robin. Show all posts

Friday, June 18, 2010

Dissecting Why All-Star Batman and Robin Leaves Fans Cold

Why does Frank Miller's All-Star Batman and Robin, the Boy Wonder (ASBRBW) really get under Batman fans' collective skins? Much has been said in reviews about the storytelling being not up to par with previous Miller efforts. There's the constant repetition of phrases which in contrast to their intention to reinforce the seriousness of certain situations (e.g.: Dick's reaction to the murder of his parents) come across as simply 'space filler'. While Miller has done this in his other Dark Knight Universe stories, it wasn't to the extent it is in ASBRBW, and in The Dark Knight Returns (TDKR) he had a lot more to say. Take out all the repeated phrases in ASBRBW and on some pages you'd be lucky to have a sentence left. Yes, ASBRBW rambles and seems to throw in females characters (Black Canary, Batgirl) just so Jim Lee can draw them in skimpy costumes. And yes, there's that annoying 'goddamn' phrase...

But is there something else? For me, I think a clue came when I was re-reading my copy of TDKR 10th Anniversary Edition. In the introduction Miller writes about what inspired him to write TDKR, who he bounced ideas off about the project, and generally about Batman. Specifically he says -
And there was Batman himself. He was the real boss. As he was quick to assert, Batman has a personality and purpose all his own, a definable core. He's neither petty nor petulant. He's no whiner; there's not a trace of self-pity in his soul. He's smart. He's noble. And most important, he's big. His passions are grand. Even his unhappiness is not depressing, but a brooding.
I think the most relevant part of this quote is - 'He's neither petty nor petulant. He's no whiner; there's not a trace of self-pity in his soul.' In TDKR this is exactly the case. In ASBRBW I'm not so sure. Cases in point

  • Batman being petty trying to impress Dick - 'Just watch, kiddo. This is gonna be great!'

  • Batman being petulant (i.e.:unreasonably irritable or ill-tempered) -
Dick: Didn't you just waste a whole pile of cops, Big Guy?
Batman: You little snot!

  • Batman whining about Dick after recruiting/kidnapping him -

'This little BRAT is going to ruin EVERYTHING.'
  • Batman not being noble - Batman throws Dick to the ground and then punches him in the face(Batman:'And stay down.') after Dick attacks Green Lantern. A thirty-two year old man punching a twelve year-old.
  • Batman displaying self-pity -

'What am I DOING to this kid? Who the hell do I think I AM?'
And later -

'What have I DONE? What have I ACCOMPLISHED? I RUSHED things. I DRAGGED him into MY world. I was RECKLESS. I RUSHED it. I BLEW it.'
I could go on. Summed up, in ASBRBW Batman displays the complete range of traits that Miller specifically says he isn't. I think it amounts to not being a hero. Sure Miller's point which he keeps stressing throughout the whole Dark Knight Universe stories is that Batman (and other heroes) have to be criminals to carry out their 'mission' against crime. That's fine. For seventy years we've known Batman is a vigilante. We like it when he gets mean with criminals and pounds them into the turf. But in ASBRBW he's also self-aggrandising, rude, contemptuous, and arrogant. Just generally unpleasant. It comes down to this: the 'Goddamn Batman' of ASBRBW is full of himself and that's just not a Batman we like.



Friday, June 11, 2010

The Dark Knight in Wonderland: Batman and... Rabbits?





The Dark Knight in Wonderland: Batman and... Rabbits?


"'what is the use of a book,' thought Alice `without pictures or conversation?'" Alice from Lewis Carrol's Alice in Wonderland

I've been re-reading the Frank Miller Batman stories that have become known as 'The Dark Knight Universe' (Batman: Year One, The Dark Knight Returns, The Dark Knight Strikes Again, and All-Star Batman and Robin, the Boy Wonder) in order to formulate an essay on the overall narrative cycle. In doing so I've noticed an animal that's popped up in the books and which seems somewhat out of place - the fluffy white rabbit. As a figure, the Rabbit in these Dark Knight stories isn't a strong motif, yet its appearance heralds an interesting portrayal of sexuality.


In The Dark Knight Returns (TDKR) Bruce Wayne dreams of an incident in his childhood where he chases a rabbit down a hole bringing to mind similarities with Lewis Carrol's Alice in Wonderland. When Alice chases the rabbit she finds -
The rabbit-hole went straight on like a tunnel for some way, and then dipped suddenly down, so suddenly that Alice had not a moment to think about stopping herself before she found herself falling down a very deep well.
Similarly Bruce's rabbit chase sees him fall into what will later become his Batcave and his first encounter with bats. In Batman Begins (Chris Nolan, dir.) young Bruce falls down an actual well which leads to the Batcave-to-be.

But the similarities between Alice and Bruce don't end in this superficiality. On his webpage The Symbolism of Rabbits and Hares Terry Windling writes -
In many mythic traditions, these animals were archetypal symbols of femininity, associated with the lunar cycle, fertility, longevity, and rebirth. But if we dig a little deeper into their stories we find that they are also contradictory, paradoxical creatures: symbols of both cleverness and foolishness, of femininity and androgyny, of cowardice and courage, of rampant sexuality and virginal purity.
Both Bruce and Alice are children on the verge of breaking into adolescence and the accompanying emergence of sexuality. Both are virgins and thus branded 'pure'.

When chasing the rabbit Bruce is warned, 'Don't go in that hole' (Miller 1996:17). Although the speaker of this warning is not in the panel we must assume it Bruce's father as the speech bubble points to him in the previous panel. Bruce of course ignores the warning and falls in. The warning is important coming from the father. Bruce is the Wayne's only child and is designated to take over the "masculine dealings" of the Wayne business estate. Symbolically Bruce is chasing his femininity which is being dominated by his father. Bruce's father, psychoanalytically speaking, sees the danger of a reconnection with the feminine which he as the father has worked hard to erase by asserting himself as 'the law'. This reconnection with the feminine will confuse Bruce dividing his allegiance due to the inability of the child to permanently go back to the womb, to be one again with the mother. As Barbara Creed writes in The Monstrous Feminine the inability for the mother and child, especially the female child, to fully separate through the Oedipal cycle produces monstrosity. In this case Batman has negotiated the Oedipal struggle yet his desire to return to the mother only to find he can't produces another kind of traumatic monster - the Bat-Man.

Not long after Bruce's parents are murdered in an alley after seeing the film The Mask of Zorro (again we could use cinema and film as representations of going into a dark cave to be find another world), and Bruce is forever divided thereafter.

Bruce awakes from the dream sequence of falling into the Batcave-to-be to find he has sleepwalked to the batcave, and is completely naked. Symbolically Bruce is reborn, returning to the place that Batman was 'created'; he has returned to the 'womb'. The feminine-associated figure of the rabbit in TDKR propels Bruce toward a fertile, feminine space/place: the Batcave.

The Batcave is where Batman keeps all his "toys"; his inventions, the feminine space underneath the masculine rigid structure of Wayne Manor, built by Bruce's father; a product of his massively successful business empire. The Batcave 'doesn't end... It just doesn't end... The cave goes on forever... And it's just getting started... It's building itself' (Miller xx) and is 'endless' (Miller 1996:199). It is here, to this maternal space that Bruce brings his SOBs (Sons of Batman) and Robin (Carrie Kelley) at the end of TDKR, a place where 'it begins' (Miller 1996: 199), to build an army, to proliferate. Interestingly, at this point Batman is supposed to be dead, but it is the Batcave Bruce Wayne returns to start a new 'good life' (Miller 1996:199), the third of Bruce Wayne's rebirths in TDKR.

But as Windling writes the rabbit also represents 'rampant sexuality and virginal purity'. An example of this can be seen in All-Star Batman and Robin, the Boy Wonder (ASBRBW). In contrast to the clearly political themes in TDKR and The Dark Knight Strikes Again (TDKSA), ASBRBW seethes with sexual energy as a thirty-two year old Batman, now reveling in his 'terrorist' role, cuts a swathe through Gotham's body of crime.

Specifically in one scene, a rabbit, which seems completely out of place, bounds out of the way of a barreling Batmobile. If we wanted to push the point, then perhaps Batman is again chasing the Rabbit, leading him again to the Batcave. At this point in ASBRBW Dick Grayson (who will become Robin) is a passenger in the Batmobile. His parents murdered only hours before, Batman has 'drafted' twelve year old Dick 'into a war'(Miller 2008:xx), and Miller repeatedly lets us know that he is twelve, and yes, Dick Grayson is therefore a boy.

Essentially ASBRBW is the story of how Batman gets Robin as his sidekick. The rabbit? It represents two things - Batman's rampant sexuality and Dick Grayson's twelve year old virginal purity. But like the rabbit running for it's life Dick Grayson is also running for his. Lucky to be alive after his parents murder, Batman rescues him and transfers him to the Batcave, that place of feminine fertility where he will incubate and emerge reborn as Robin, the Boy Wonder. Batman tells him to choose a name and costume. Dick proclaims himself 'Hood' after the mythical Robin Hood. Batman disapproves, 'You're Robin.' (Miller 2008:xx) he says, and in naming him thus becomes his surrogate father in Robin's genesis.

Of course Batman stories themselves have bred like rabbits over the last seventy years and there looks like there's no stopping them any time soon.


Reference

Miller, F. (w). Lee, J.(p), and Williams, S.(i) (2008). All-Star Batman and Robin, the Boy Wonder, Volume 1. New York:DC Comics.[Collecting All-Star Batman and Robin #1-9, 2005-08].

Miller, F.(w,a) and Varley, L.(i) (1996).
The Dark Knight Returns. 10th Anniversary Edition.
New York:DC Comics.[Collecting The Dark Knight Returns #1-4, 1985]

Windling, T. (2005).
The Symbolism of Rabbits and Hares. at http://www.endicott-studio.com/rdrm/rrRabbits.html